Welcome to Nicky's on the Bay
Nicky's on the Bay invites you to experience a culinary journey along the shores of Bay Shore, NY. With breathtaking views of the water, this restaurant merges stunning scenery with an enticing menu that celebrates fresh seafood and local flavors. Signature dishes like the Thai Chili Calamari and melt-in-your-mouth Braised Short Rib highlight the quality and creativity of the kitchen. Guests rave about the vibrant atmosphere, complemented by attentive service and delicious cocktails. Whether indulging in their famous lobster rolls or basking in the tranquil ambiance, Nicky's guarantees a memorable dining adventure that captures the essence of waterfront indulgence.
-
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States Hotline: +1 631-892-6694
Welcome to Nicky's on the Bay, a culinary gem nestled along the picturesque waterfront at 150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706. This vibrant restaurant offers a captivating dining experience that seamlessly blends exceptional seafood with stunning views of passing ferries and boats. Whether you’re looking for a casual bite or a more indulgent feast, Nicky's has something special for everyone.
From the moment you step inside, you are greeted by a lively atmosphere that sets the tone for a memorable meal. Customers have praised the outdoor seating, allowing them to enjoy a refreshing sea breeze while savoring their dishes. The dedicated staff, such as the attentive servers like Kat, ensure every visit is both personal and enjoyable.
- Starters: Begin your culinary journey with Nicky's Fried Calamari, served with marinara and lemon aioli, or indulge in the Grilled Portuguese Octopus with romesco puree and chorizo bits. Don’t miss the Mediterranean Platter, a perfect shareable assortment that includes red pepper hummus and spiced feta spread.
- Raw Bar Delights: The Colossal Crabmeat Cocktail and the freshly shucked West Coast and East Coast Oysters are testament to the freshness and quality that Nicky's commits to daily.
- Entrees: For those craving a hearty meal, the Braised Short Rib is often noted as “melt-in-your-mouth tender,” while the warmly received Lobster Roll boasts large chunks of sweet, buttery lobster, perfectly paired with hand-cut fries.
- Desserts: Save room for a delicious dessert; the Monkey Bread a la mode is a crowd favorite, striking the perfect balance between sweetness and richness.
Customers have consistently lauded Nicky's for its freshness and quality, noting that even the more casual fare, like the Jumbo BBQ Sriracha Wings, holds its own. While some diners suggest the prices may be on the higher side, many agree that the exceptional quality and breathtaking views make every penny worth it.
The atmosphere, coupled with a menu that emphasizes fresh ingredients, makes Nicky's on the Bay a perfect spot for any occasion—be it a romantic dinner, a family celebration, or a night out with friends. It's a destination that invites you to unwind while savoring the best that waterfront dining has to offer. Whether you're a seafood lover or simply looking to enjoy a meal with a view, Nicky's on the Bay promises an unforgettable culinary adventure.
We so enjoyed our first visit to Nicky’s on Sunday . The atmosphere was fantastic. A gorgeous view and we loved watching all the ferrys and boats passing by. Our server Kat was the best. She offered up suggestions to us as it was our first time and she was on point. I’m not much of a seafood eater so she suggested the short ribs and they were like butter. Appetizers of mussels and clams and even the shrimp cocktail were so fresh and just the right way to start the meal. My husband and daughter both had the Parmesan Halibut and both plates were cleaned!!! We ended our night with the monkey bread a la mode and it was just right. Not too sweet and the ice cream was refreshing. Drinks were great (and strong). Things quickly added up and the bill was high but you pay for the freshness and for the view. We will definitely be retuning. Maybe on a night with some live music.
We loved it. The fried clams are their specialty and the portion was huge. Great prices too. Everything was covid safe and the service was on point. Not a long wait. Beautiful on the water outdoor seating with a sea breeze to cool the day. Today we had the lobster rolls. And the baked clams. Huge chunks of delicious lobster
This was my first time here and everything about this place was amazing! We sat outside and watched all the ferries go by while sipping a delicious espresso martini. The lobster roll was amazing highly recommend!
Everything was great the lobster was great the crab cakes were amazing, the clams however we're not your typical clams , there weren't full clams in there , the rib meal was good according to my father, but it's more of a Bolognese pasta ordeal . No bad food just being honest, loved the place and the atmosphere and was very Happy with the food .
Nicky’s on the Bay exceeded all expectations. The Thai Chili Calamari and Crab Cakes were the perfect start—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The Braised Short Rib was melt-in-your-mouth tender, and the Halibut was spot on. Incredible food, great atmosphere—highly recommend.
The food is still amazing and spectacular service and a nice view of the ferries and boats! This time around I was able to have a perfect view of the Harvest moon. For a starter try: MUSSEL POT DU JOUR chefs speciality Entree: LOBSTER ROLL: warm: butter poached, lemon aioli, handcut fries
Very romantic, food was extremely fresh, homemade dipping sauces extremely fresh great quality, professional and persistent staff. Beautiful scenery, on the expensive side however was definitely worth it would come again. Drinks were Made very well.
I love my margarita en the crab . So beautiful. To many fried food in the menú . No fan of their menu